What an investment policy statement should do
An investment policy statement (IPS) turns a committee's intentions into written rules. A useful IPS records the purpose of the assets, the return and risk objectives the committee has chosen, spending or liquidity needs, permitted and prohibited investments, allocation ranges, the roles of the committee, adviser and managers, and how often everything is reviewed.
The test of a good IPS is simple: a new committee member should be able to read it and understand why the portfolio looks the way it does. Review the document on a regular schedule and whenever the organization's circumstances change, such as a new spending policy, a change in liabilities or a shift in governance.
Questions to ask when evaluating an OCIO arrangement
- Authority: What decisions are delegated, within which ranges and restrictions, and what still requires your approval?
- Fees: What does the adviser charge, what do managers and funds charge separately, and who pays custody and trading costs?
- Conflicts: Does the adviser or an affiliate receive compensation from managers, platforms or product providers? Where is that disclosed?
- Reporting: How often will you receive reports, against which benchmarks, and in what format?
- Exit: How can either party terminate, and what happens to prepaid fees and holdings?
Answers should be in the agreement and in the adviser's Form ADV, not only in a sales conversation.
How to read a performance report
Start with the benchmark. Confirm it matches the policy statement, then look at the time periods shown. Short periods can be noisy, so compare results over several periods and market environments. Look at fees: reports may be shown before or after fees, and the difference matters.
Next, ask what explains the result. Attribution can show how much came from the allocation decision versus manager selection. Finally, compare each manager with what it was hired to do. A manager can trail a broad index and still be doing its job in the portfolio, or lead an index while taking risks the committee did not intend.